Florida jury awards $10.5 million in the case of two teens killed in fiery Tesla crash

A federal jury in Florida has found Tesla negligent in a 2018 crash that killed two teens and found one of the teens 90% responsible for his role in the collision.


Plaintiff James Riley, the father of one of the teens, alleged Tesla was responsible for the death of his son, 18-year-old Barrett, because batteries installed in the 2014 Model S sedan the teen was driving ignited after the electric car crashed in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. while traveling at 116 mph.

Riley said Barrett and the other crash victim, 18-year-old Edgar Monserratt Martinez, initially survived the collision when the Tesla’s airbags deployed but died after the car caught fire.

Riley also claimed a Tesla technician had, without his consent, removed a speed limiter the family had installed on the car.

Right side of car, showing severe crash and fire damage from the 2018 crash of a Tesla Model S.NTSB

Tesla countered that the speed limiter could not have prevented the crash at the speed the teenagers were traveling at, and that Riley failed to establish that the battery was defective.

In its verdict, the jury placed the majority of the blame for the crash on Barrett, who Investigators said was driving 116 mph into a 25-mph curve before the collision. Barrett had a history of speeding, having been ticketed just two months before the fatal crash for traveling at 112 mph. The jury placed 9% of the blame on James Riley himself.

The jury awarded $10.5 million in damages.

“We are pleased that, in what we understand to be the first case to go to trial against Tesla involving an accident involving one of their vehicles, the jury found Tesla to have been negligent in removing the speed limiter without letting Mr. or Mrs. Riley knows,” an attorney for the Rileys said in a statement.

Another family recently hired a prominent Florida personal injury firm following a crash of a 2015 Tesla Model S earlier this month that killed two people.


What do you think?


Felony charges filed against Charlotte Hornets’ Miles Bridges for domestic violence, child abuse

Secret Service turned over just one text message to January 6 panel, sources say | January 6 hearings