Mortgage rates and home prices are keeping renters from becoming homeowners

Aspiring first-time homeowners are sailing into fierce macroeconomic headwinds as prices and mortgage rates rise, while higher rents make it harder to save for a down payment.


Why it matters: Homeownership is a foundation for middle-class Americans to build long-term wealth. If people can’t afford homes, that American dream becomes even less attainable.

  • Plus, homes provide a sense of stability. Assuming you’ve got a fixed-rate mortgage, there’s no equivalent of the Landlord hiking your rent every year. (There are, however, plenty of Unexpected costs — take it from me, a guy who just got a $2,000 bill to replace corroded pipes.)

Three factors are keeping people stuck in the rent trap.

Rising rents: Rents are up 0.8% over the last month alone, per the government’s latest Consumer Price Index — “the largest monthly increase since April 1986.” They’re up a staggering 5.8% year-over-year, too.

  • That’s a problem for anybody trying to save up enough cash for a down payment — as is inflation more broadly.

Rising rates: As the Federal Reserve raises interest rates to fight inflation, mortgage rates are rising in kind. This week’s going rate for an average 30-year fixed rate mortgage is 5.5%, compared to around 3% at the end of last year.

  • For a $350,000 loan, that’s a difference of $1,987 in monthly payments vs. $1,476 — or $6,132 annually. Ouch. (And as Axios’ Emily Peck notes, other sources show even higher rent increases.)

Rising prices: The average home went for $507,800 last quarter, per the US Census Bureau. Compare that to the first quarter of 2020 — just before the COVID-19 Pandemic — when the average home swapped hands for $383,000.

  • Real estate data firm ATTOM recently found that “median-priced single-family homes and Condos are less affordable in the second quarter of 2022 compared to historical averages in 97% of counties across the Nation with enough data to analyze.”
  • Costs associated with homeownership — think maintenance and other stuff renters don’t pay for directly — are at “the highest point since the second quarter of 2007,” per ATTOM, another factor potentially discouraging first-time homebuyers.

Yes, but: At least one trend is pointing in homebuyers’ favor: More listings are hitting the market, which could help suppress prices by increasing supply.

  • “The national Inventory of active listings increased by 18.7% over last year” in June, per
  • Still, that number was down 34.1% compared to June 2020, and 53.2% compared to June 2019. “In other words, there are a little less than two-thirds the number of homes available compared to June 2020, and less than half compared to June 2019.”
  • And fewer homes are being built, fueling a long-running housing shortage.

The other side: From a purely financial point of view, homeownership isn’t always all it’s cracked up to be. “We all know people who bought a home and then regretted it,” Axios’ Felix Salmon wrote a while back. “As Americans delay homeownership, they’re more aware of the possible downsides, more attuned to the idea that their home could turn out to be more of a liability than an asset.”

💬 Our thought bubble: What a mess. My heart goes out to anyone trying to save up for a house right now.

The big picture: People are still buying houses — nearly 700,000 new single-family homes were sold in May 2022 alone, seasonally adjusted. It’s just harder and harder to get the keys.



What do you think?


Where does Barcelona’s Lewandowski deal leave the likes of Aubameyang and Ferran?

Juan Soto rejects $440 million offer; Nationals will entertain trade proposals: Sources